What Are the Best Over the Counter Skin Tag Removal Products?

If you have skin tags in your armpits, on the side of your neck, around your eyes, and elsewhere on your body there is no need to be concerned. The best over-the-counter skin tag removal products, creams, and kits work fast to safely remove any imperfections from your skin.

Scientists are unsure of why skin tags appear. The most plausible explanation is that they are due to friction. It stands to reason given where they form. That said, friction is not the only factor. Genetics, hormones, pregnancy, and obesity can also lead to this condition.

Although nobody is sure of the exact cause, we do know which top rated products for the removal of skin tags work. Some utilize the healing powers of essential oils. Others are pharmaceutical or involve proven techniques for removing a skin tag quickly. The only thing that you need to decide is which method you want to use to get rid of skin tags at home.

We aim to make the process as simple as possible. We’ve put together a comparison table that contrasts the features of each OTC product. Before exploring the table, we recommend that you scrutinize the factors that are the most important in reaching a decision.

What Makes A Good Skin Tag Remover?

There are many ways of removing skin tags at home. With so many options available, it can be hard to make the right decision. Many companies make bold claims about what their products can do for your skin, but they aren’t always truthful or accurate.

Here are the factors to consider when you want to know how to remove a skin tag yourself:

  1. Quick results: Choose a product that is easy to apply (or use), and removes a skin tag fast. There are single-application treatments available that get results almost instantly. You won’t have to wait for months for your skin tags to go away entirely.
  2. Simple to use: The best skin tag products should be safe and straightforward to use at home without the need for any medical training. For example, if you’re removing skin tags that are near the eyes, you don’t want to be applying a runny or overly thick liquid.
  3. Natural: You may prefer a product that is derived from plant or mineral extracts, such as tea tree oil for skin tag removal. There are loads of natural treatments being touted as a cure for skin tags, but most of them don’t work.
  4. Don’t cause any pain: Depending on how sensitive you are to pain, it may be worth choosing a treatment that is painless (or only causes mild irritation). Extra care needs to be taken when treating particularly sensitive areas, like the groin region, penis, and anus.
  5. Affordability: Obviously, at-home skin tag removers are cost-effective when compared to seeing a doctor or dermatologist. Pricing does vary based on the option that you select, but there are many products for removing skin tags that cost just $20 to $40.
  6. Low risk of scarring: Choose purpose-made over the counter products to remove skin tags safely and not cause long-term damage to your skin. Make sure that you adhere to the instructions and follow any advice on aftercare (if applicable).

You’ll find an assessment of the criteria (in the table below). Click on the “CHECK PRICE” link to get the latest pricing info, read customer reviews, find out how it works, etc.

Best Over the Counter Skin Tag Removal Products [Table]

OTC Product:Pricing InfoWorks:Speed:Simplicity:Safe:Value:
TagBand Skin Tag Removal DeviceCHECK PRICE9.5/109/109/109/10$$$$$
Apothecary Tea Tree Oil for skin tagsCHECK PRICE8.5/105/107/1010/10$$$$
wart-and-mole-vanish skin tag removerCHECK PRICE8/1010/108.5/105/10$$$
HaloDerm Advanced Mole and Skin Tag Remover ReviewCHECK PRICE7/109/107/105/10$$$
BuyNaturally reviewCHECK PRICE6.5/109/107/105/10$$
Kungber Mole Removal PenCHECK PRICE6/1010/108.5/105/10$$$
Dr.-Scholls-Freeze-Away-Wart-Remover ReviewCHECK PRICE6/107/108/107/10$$$
  • Keep reading for extra information on the treatments (above). We’ve expanded on each of the products that remove skin tags in more detail and included a summary of the advantages and disadvantages.

Why Do People Want to Remove Skin Tags?

People remove skin tags due to the way they look. They are benign but can look ugly. Most appear in locations where they cannot be seen in public, such as the armpits, anus, and groin. Unfortunately, some will form on the face and around the eyes, which can be irritating and embarrassing.

The problem is made worse when many skin tags appear in a cluster in the same area. This often happens to the neck and around the eyelids. Some people (and parts of the body) are more prone to this skin condition than others.

Skin tags can catch or rub against clothing and jewelry. This can lead to physical irritation, infection, and bleeding.

What’s the Best Way to Remove Skin Tags in 2018?

1/ TagBand Device

Get Results with the TagBand Skin Tag Removal DeviceWhen you want to know how to remove skin tags at home, the TagBand removal kit is one of the best options.

The idea behind it is based on the oldest way of removing skin tags: tying them off using thread so that the tissue dies and falls off. The problem with ligation is that it’s inconsistent: you have to tie the thread just right and leave it undisturbed, for it to work. Things are now so much easier.

The ‘TagBand’ is a complete skin tag removal kit, not just a band. It comes with a unique applicator and many strong elasticized bands. Using the applicator, you stretch the band and place it around the skin tag. The TagBand applicator makes the process much more straightforward than tying it off on your own.

Once the band is in place, it will take only 7 to 10 days for the skin tag to fall off. First, the tissue of the skin tag will change color, becoming purple or black. This is a natural reaction as the tissue dies. Other than a slight tingling sensation at the outset, the process is painless.

What Are the Pros?

  • The process only needs to be carried out once. It’s a set-and-forget treatment, so it’s ideal for people who lead hectic lifestyles.
  • You will get fast results. The average time it takes for your skin tag to drop off is approximately one week. And, of course, results are permanent, as skin tags don’t grow back.
  • It’s much cheaper than paying for your skin tag to be removed by a dermatologist.
  • The TagBand is far easier to use than trying to tie off skin tags with string.
  • It’s safer to use and much more hygienic. You’re unlikely to experience any weeping due to an infection/irritation.
  • You can remove up to ten skin tags with one kit. You can also buy more bands at a reduced price (should this be necessary).

What Are the Cons?

  • The TagBand comes in two sizes. The Tagband skin tag removal device is for medium and large-sized skin tags. The Micro TagBand is intended for smaller-sized skin tags. You need to select the right device based on the size of your skin tag. If you get this wrong, the band won’t be secured tightly enough, so it won’t work.
  • Despite the applicator, some areas of the body can be difficult to reach. You may need assistance from someone before releasing the band.
  • It’s not suitable for those tiny skin tags because the band won’t form a sufficient seal.

Read Our Review of the TagBand Device!

2/ Apothecary Tea Tree Oil

How to Use Apothecary Australian Tea Tree Oil for Skin TagsTea tree oil is an essential oil which is extracted from the leaves of the Melaleuca Alternifolia plant. It is a pale, clear liquid with a strong smell. Although it’s toxic if consumed, it has many beneficial properties and can work wonders for your skin.

Apothecary tea tree oil works by drying out the skin over many weeks so that the skin tag eventually shrinks and falls off. So if you’re looking for an all-natural way to remove your skin tags, tea tree oil is the safest option.

Like any other topical ointment, tea tree oil is applied directly to the area. It’s recommended to combine it with other oils, such as grapeseed oil. This is because it is surprisingly strong, and can irritate the skin (for some people) after repeated applications.

What Are the Pros?

  • Tea tree oil is beneficial for the skin, which is why cosmetics brands use it in their products.
  • It’s all-natural. You don’t need to worry about your skin coming into contact with chemicals. This means that there is no risk of scarring.
  • It can be used to treat many skin tags and lasts a long time. It’s excellent value for money.

What Are the Cons?

  • Tea tree oil can irritate the skin, so it’s a good idea to dilute it slightly.
  • It’s poisonous if consumed, so keep it out of the reach of children and pets.
  • Skin tag removal with tea tree oil is not instant – it requires regular applications (up to three times daily) and can take 6 to 12 weeks to work.

Read Our Review of Apothecary Tea Tree Oil!

3/ Pristine Wart & Mole Vanish

Pristine Herbal touch wart mole vanish skin tag removerWart Mole Vanish by Pristine is a cream which can be used to remove all sorts of skin growths, including warts, moles, and syringoma. Although it doesn’t have ‘skin tag’ in the name, it can be used to remove them.

It’s a unique product that works by inducing the natural cauterization of skin cells. It achieves this in one 20-minute application, though some larger growths may require a second application.

Unlike using a cauterization tool, Pristine Wart Mole Vanish is an herbal cream. It’s made from all-natural ingredients such as lemon, fig plant, and cashew plant.

It’s easy to apply, and the kit contains everything you need to remove skin tags on the face, neck, eyelids, and more at home – the cream itself, an antibacterial solution, cotton swabs, and applicator sticks.

The amount you get is enough for 2 to 5 larger skin tags or 5 to 25 smaller ones, so it’s excellent value for money.

What Are the Pros?

  • Wart Mole Vanish is 100% natural as it’s derived from plants.
  • It’s quick and easy: 90% of skin tags will be successfully removed with one rapid treatment, so there’s usually no need to reapply.
  • Your skin tags will be gone in just 20 minutes.
  • It’s less expensive than having your skin tag cauterized by a dermatologist.

What Are the Cons?

  • As it uses cauterization, there is a chance that Wart Mole Vanish will produce a blemish or scar if you pick off the scab early. You may wish to cover up the area with a band-aid to prevent the scab from becoming dislodged.
  • Even though you only need to apply the cream once and the skin tag will be gone in twenty minutes, the scab will take a week or two to fall off.
  • The skin tag removal cost is higher than the other leading OTC remedies.

Read Our Review of Pristine Wart Mole Vanish!

4/ HaloDerm Advanced Mole and Skin Tag Remover

products for removing skin tags safelyHaloDerm Advanced Mole and Skin Tag Remover is another cream that is similar to Wart Mole Vanish. This one is marketed for removing skin tags and does the job very well. It comes in the form of a small tube, with enough cream for up to 5 skin tags.

The cream’s two main active ingredients are naturally derived: zinc chloride and Sanguinaria Canadensis extract (commonly known as bloodroot).

It does have some inactive ingredients including a preservative. The product boasts that it can remove skin tags in as little as 8 hours, after one application – though this does vary depending on the size of the skin tag.

What Are the Pros?

  • HaloDerm Advanced Mole and Skin Tag Remover is easy to use, and quick to apply.
  • Skin tags will usually be removed 24 hours after application, but you’ll still need to wait for the skin to heal and return to its natural color before the healing process has been completed.
  • The tube contains enough cream for up to 5 skin tags or up to 5 applications. The handy tube means that it can be stored away for the future if you just have the one growth to treat.

What Are the Cons?

  • When applied, the cream can cause a slight stinging or burning sensation. Be careful not to get it on any healthy skin. If you do, wash it away without delay.
  • It also doesn’t come with an antibacterial solution to prevent infection, so you’ll have to buy that separately.
  • If you disturb the scab before the healing process has completed, there is a risk of scarring.

Read Our Review of HaloDerm Advanced Mole and Skin Tag Remover!

5/ BuyNaturally Skin Tag and Wart Remover

Skin Tag & Wart Remover Kit reviewBuyNaturally has produced another homeopathic treatment created using only natural ingredients. It comes in the form of a paste. Many of the ingredients are the same as the HaloDerm cream, such as bloodroot and zinc oxide. However, the BuyNaturally cream has another vital ingredient: Thuja Occidentalis, which is extracted from an evergreen tree. This is used in other favorite OTC skin tag removers, such as Revitol.

Unlike the HaloDerm cream, BuyNaturally provides everything that you need for application: cotton swabs, adhesive bandages, and after-healing cream. It also comes with an applicator spatula for the skin tag removal cream, roughing needle and emery boards. The emery boards should only be used for warts and not skin tags.

The paste is quick to apply, and only one or two uses are needed. After application, your skin tag could fall off in as little as two days. The skin will recover gradually over the next few weeks.

What Are the Pros?

  • It is an all-natural product, but it still cauterizes the skin.
  • Small skin tags usually only require one application to be removed.
  • The skin tag removal kit contains everything you need to get the job done from start to finish.

What Are the Cons?

  • Because of the nature of the paste, it can be quite tricky to apply without getting any on the surrounding skin. This can cause a burning or stinging sensation.
  • The paste causes the skin tag to scab over. If you disturb the scab, scarring can occur.

Read Our Review of BuyNaturally Skin Tag and Wart Remover!

6/ Kungber Mole Removal Pen

Although advertised as a mole removal device, the Kungber Mole Removal Pen is suitable for a wide variety of skin blemishes, such as warts and skin tags. It’s a relatively new product which works using cauterization.

The pen itself is chargeable, and when switched on heats up. There are six strength levels to choose from, and two interchangeable needles – a smaller one for small freckles and a larger one for skin tags, warts and moles.

The device works by burning the skin tag off. To use, switch the device on, wait for it to heat up, and gently sweep it over the area. You may feel a stinging sensation, though this should not last for long.

After use, the skin tag should scab over, and fall off within a few days. It may be necessary to repeat the procedure for larger skin tags.

What Are the Pros?

  • The device is rechargeable via USB, so you don’t need to worry about changing batteries or plugging it into the mains.
  • Skin tags are removed quickly, with the same method of cauterization used by dermatologists.
  • There’s no need for repeated use of creams or ointments.

What Are the Cons?

  • The device can be painful to use. You may choose to purchase a numbing cream.
  • As with all forms of cauterization, there is a risk of scarring. Also, it’s not suitable for extremely large skin tags.

7/ Compound W Freeze Off Wart Removal System

Compound W Freeze OffAgain, don’t be put off by this product being sold as a wart remover – you can also use the Compound W Freeze Off Wart Removal system for freezing off skin tags. It works through the process of cryotherapy, which means it freezes off your skin tag using liquid nitrogen.

Exposing your skin tag to extreme cold causes the cells to die. So once you apply the product, your skin tag will start to turn black, and eventually fall off. If your skin tag is tiny, it could fall off in a few days, though for larger ones it could take several weeks.

Most skin tags will only require one quick application, though for large skin tags you might need to apply it once more. The product is straightforward to use and comes with a precision tip so that it doesn’t touch the rest of your skin.

What Are the Pros?

  • Compound W Freeze Off uses liquid nitrogen to freeze off skin tags, but it’s cheaper than visiting a doctor.
  • It’s simple to use and takes seconds to apply. Usually, only one application.
  • Scarring is extremely rare.

What Are the Cons?

  • You might experience a stinging feeling after application. This goes away. The treated area usually feels sensitive for a few days.
  • Although it’s easy to use, if you accidentally apply Compound W Freeze Off to your healthy skin, it may sting.

Read Our Review of Compound W Freeze Off Wart Removal system!

Is Skin Tag Removal Covered By Insurance?

The procedure is not usually covered by insurance or Medicare. It is not considered medically necessary. As we pointed out, skin tag removal at home is usually carried out for aesthetic reasons. That being said, your insurance may cover the cost if your skin tags have led to a nasty infection.

You will be able to get skin tags removed by a doctor under your insurance plan if a biopsy is required. For example, if further medical checks are needed to make sure that you don’t have a malignant melanoma. That is a genuine medical concern and would be covered.

The same applies if your skin tag is really large. Some continue to grow until they reach the size of a grape (or larger), which can be uncomfortable. Skin tags of such a large size may affect your quality of life. Your insurance may cover their removal if that applies.

Bear in mind that everyone is different, and all tumors are different. What treatment works for one person might not work for you. Nevertheless, with so many excellent options (not all of them are available at Walgreens, Walmart, and CVS) out there. You’re bound to find the best over the counter skin tag removal product. We recommend the TagBand device.